Yellow Fever in South America and the Failure of the Noguchi Vaccine
Rockefeller Foundation Conducts Studies in South America and Hanson Works in Peru
In 1916, the Rockefeller Foundation Yellow Fever Commission was formed, and work began in South America with studies conducted in Ecuador, Peru, Colombia, Venezuela, and Brazil. Only Guayaquil, Ecuador was deemed an endemic center. Locating and destroying endemic centers or “key-centers” was crucial to the attack plan. As Wickcliffe Rose stated, “Endemic centers are the seed-beds without which there can be no epidemics.” Despite the U.S. entry into World War I, a special commission to study yellow fever was appointed in 1918, and experts in clinical medicine, pathology, bacteriology, and chemistry were sent to Guayaquil to search for the causative agent of yellow fever. Interestingly, in 1918, an effort to eradicate mosquitoes in Guayaquil led to validation of Carter’s estimate of a time-frame for elimination. By the end of 1918 there were 25 anti-mosquito squads and by mid-1919, there were no reported cases of yellow fever with the result that for the first time in almost a century the city was free of the disease.
The Commission’s bacteriologist was a well-known Japanese scientist, Hideyo Noguchi, who had achieved fame at the Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research by successfully “growing the causative agent of syphilis: the spirochete Treponema pallidum (now known as Spirochaeta pallida).” While working in Guayaquil in 1918, Noguchi identified another spirochete, Leptospira icteroides (“slim spiral, the jaundice resembler”), as the cause of yellow fever.
Noguchi’s claim that yellow fever was caused by a bacterium went directly against the discoveries made by the Walter Reed Commission, specifically by James Carroll, back in 1902. Carroll had determined that the agent that caused yellow fever could pass through a bacteria-proof filter and therefore was smaller than a bacterium.
Following World War I, the Peruvian government recruited Dr. Henry Hanson, stationed with the Army Medical Corps in Panama, to “study sanitary conditions in [the] Province of Lima and the Rimac Valley, with special reference to malaria.” Hanson’s time in Peru began when he was 42 in the fall of 1919 and ended in July 1922 and resulted in work not only on malaria, but also bubonic plague and yellow fever. In Peru Dr. Hanson met the “Big Four,” as he described them, in yellow fever research: Henry Rose Carter, William C. Gorgas, Joseph Hill White, and Noguchi. It was also in Peru that Hanson had two memorable experiences: he was stricken by yellow fever in Piura not long after arriving; and in spite of understandable, local opposition, he relocated 600 residents of Paita before burning down their rat-infested buildings, thus ending the bubonic plague outbreak.
Just before the burning of Paita, Noguchi briefly visited the town and “decided to test the Pfeiffer phenomenon.” Hanson described the procedure: “To do this they took blood from a group of people who had had yellow fever within the last few months. The blood of such people is lytic to the bacterium or agent responsible for the diseases; which means that when a culture of the organism and blood from such a recovered case is mixed, it causes the etiologic organism to disintegrate, a phenomenon known as bacteriolysis.” Noguchi mixed L. icteroides with blood from people who had been diagnosed with yellow fever and observed destruction of the L. icteroides.
Although Noguchi cautioned in a 1920 article that more testing needed to be conducted and that L. icteroides could not yet be “certainly established” as the inciting agent of yellow fever, he created a vaccine and immune serum from his cultures.
A December 10, 1920 New York Times article that encouraged travelers to South and Central America to get the “Noguchi vaccine” stated, “the efficacy of the vaccine seems to be thoroughly established … there is no ‘kick’ from the vaccine at all.”
The Rockefeller Foundation’s 1921 Annual Report reported that the “experience with Noguchi’s vaccine and serum indicated that the former when properly administered affords a marked protection against attacks of yellow fever, and that the latter if it is used on or before the third day of the onset of the disease reduces the mortality in a striking way.” By September of 1921 over 525 people had been inoculated with the Noguchi vaccine in Peru alone by Dr. Hanson or under his direction.
Noguchi carried on his experiments and continued to have a positive Pfeiffer reaction. In June of 1923 he used serum from Hanson whose yellow fever infection had been four years earlier. In his paper, “The Pfeiffer Reaction in Yellow Fever” he stated that Dr. Hanson was one of the doctors performing the experiments and observations.
In 1926 Max Theiler and Andrew Watson Sellards published an article that raised the possibility that L. Icteroides might not be the causative agent of yellow fever. The Foundation quietly stopped distributing the Noguchi vaccine the same year. Both Noguchi and Hanson would continue their work studying yellow fever in West Africa.
-  George K. Strode, ed. and John C. Bugher et al., Yellow Fever (New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1951), 14.
-  Wickliffe Rose, “Yellow Fever: Feasibility of its Eradication,” October 27, 1914, Hench-Reed Collection, Historical Collections, CMHSL, University of Virginia, 5, http://etext.lib.virginia.edu/etcbin/fever-browse?id=00757001 (accessed July 25, 2012).
-  The College of Physicians of Philadelphia, “1918 Anti-Mosquito Methods Control Yellow Fever in Ecuador,” The History of Vaccines, Timelines, 2012, http://www.historyofvaccines.org/content/timelines/all (accessed July 25, 2012).
-  James Edward Peabody, “The Conquest of Yellow Fever,” 23, Hench-Reed Collection, Historical Collections, CMHSL, University of Virginia, http://etext.lib.virginia.edu/etcbin/fever-browse?id=KAMD1460 (accessed July 25, 2012).
-  Joseph Luna, “Hideyo Noguchi’s Bust Is Back in Welch Hall,” Natural Selections, The Rockefeller University, posted May 2, 2013,http://selections.rockefeller.edu/hideyo-noguchis-bust-is-back-in-welch-hall/ (accessed August 7, 2013).
-  Raymond B. Fosdick, The Story of the Rockefeller Foundation (New York: Harper & Brothers, 1952), 61.
-  Walter Reed and James Carroll, “The Etiology of Yellow Fever (A Supplemental Note),” American Medicine 3, no. 8 (February 22, 1902): 301-305, http://yellowfever.lib.virginia.edu/reed/commission.html#_edn18 and http://tinyurl.com/6vc4gvt (accessed July 25, 2012).
-  Henry Hanson, The Pied Piper of Peru: Dr. Henry Hanson’s Fight against “Yellow Jack” and Bubonic Plague in South America, 1919-1922, ed. Doris M. Hurnie (Jacksonville, Fla.: Convention Press, 1961), 1, http://hdl.handle.net/2027/mdp.39015010649146 (accessed July 25, 2012).
-  Henry Hanson, The Pied Piper of Peru: Dr. Henry Hanson’s Fight against “Yellow Jack” and Bubonic Plague in South America, 1919-1922, ed. Doris M. Hurnie (Jacksonville, Fla.: Convention Press, 1961), 155, http://hdl.handle.net/2027/mdp.39015010649146 (accessed July 25, 2012).
-  Henry Hanson, The Pied Piper of Peru: Dr. Henry Hanson’s Fight against “Yellow Jack” and Bubonic Plague in South America, 1919-1922, ed. Doris M. Hurnie (Jacksonville, Fla.: Convention Press, 1961), 39, 77, http://hdl.handle.net/2027/mdp.39015010649146 (accessed July 25, 2012).
-  Henry Hanson, The Pied Piper of Peru: Dr. Henry Hanson’s Fight against “Yellow Jack” and Bubonic Plague in South America, 1919-1922, ed. Doris M. Hurnie (Jacksonville, Fla.: Convention Press, 1961), 84, http://hdl.handle.net/2027/mdp.39015010649146 (accessed July 25, 2012).
-  Hideyo Noguchi and I.J. Kligler, “Immunology of the Peruvian Strains of Leptospira Icteroides,” Journal of Experimental Medicine 33, no. 2 (January 31, 1921): 260, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2128174/pdf/253.pdf (accessed August 15, 2012).
-  Hideyo Noguchi, “Leptospira icteroides and Yellow Fever,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 6, no. 3 (March 1920): 110-11, http://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015078006874 (accessed July 25, 2012).
-  “Have Noguchi Vaccine,” New York Times, December 10, 1920.
-  The Rockefeller Foundation Annual Report,1921(New York: The Rockefeller Foundation, ), 54, http://www.rockefellerfoundation.org/uploads/files/599ac1c3-7af0-48b1-917f-4b81c39da2be-1921.pdf (accessed July 25, 2012).
-  Marcos Cueto, “Sanitation from Above: Yellow Fever and Foreign Intervention in Peru, 1919-1922,” The Hispanic American Historical Review 72, no. 1 (February 1992): 15, http://www.jstor.org/stable/2515945 (accessed July 25, 2012).
-  Hideyo Noguchi, “The Pfeiffer Reaction in Yellow Fever,” American Journal of Tropical Medicine 4, no. 2 (March 1924): 134, www.ajtmh.org/content/s1-4/2/131.full.pdf+html (accessed July 25, 2012).
-  Max Theiler and Andrew Watson Sellards, “The Relationship of L. Icterohaemorrhagiae and L. Icteroides as Determined by the Pfeiffer Phenomenon in Guinea Pigs,” American Journal of Tropical Medicine 6, no. 6 (November 1926): 402, http://www.ajtmh.org/content/s1-6/6/383.full.pdf+html (accessed August 14, 2012).
-  J. Gordon Frierson, “The Yellow Fever Vaccine: A History,” Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine 83, no. 2 (June 2010): 78 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2892770/ (accessed August 14, 2012).